This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through these links, at no extra cost to you.
Look, I’ve had chickens for eleven years and I’ve made basically every mistake you can make. I bought “heritage breeds” because they were pretty and discovered that pretty doesn’t pay the feed bill. I bought the “dual-purpose” birds because I thought I’d be clever and butcher the extras, then couldn’t bring myself to actually do it and ended up feeding a rooster named Gerald for two years.
We now run 14 laying hens on about a quarter acre behind the house. We average 10-12 eggs per day most of the year, which keeps us in eggs plus we sell the surplus to two neighbors every week. That extra covers most of the feed cost.
Here’s what I actually learned about which breeds work, which don’t, and what you’re really buying when you pick a chicken.
Table of Contents
- How to Evaluate Egg Production
- Top Laying Breeds That Actually Deliver
- Breeds for Cold Climates
- What About Easter Eggers and Colored Eggs?
- Breeds to Avoid If You Want Eggs
- Mixed Flock Strategy
- Buying Chicks vs. Pullets vs. Hatching Eggs
- What I’d Actually Buy Today
How to Evaluate Egg Production {#evaluating-production}
Egg production claims are all over the place. “Up to 300 eggs per year!” sounds great until you realize that number comes from ideal commercial conditions — controlled lighting, commercial feed formulated to maximize production, optimal temperature. Backyard conditions produce lower numbers.
When I compare breeds, I’m looking at a few things. Real annual production matters — not the commercial numbers, but what you’d actually get in a backyard flock, which is usually 15-25% lower. Production longevity matters too: some birds peak hard in year one and drop sharply, while others produce more steadily for 3-4 years. Winter laying is worth checking — do they go broody for months or do they push through shorter days reasonably well? Temperament counts more than people admit, especially with kids. And size affects feed cost in ways that sneak up on you: Leghorns are small and efficient, but Brahmas eat a lot more per egg produced.
I keep a rough record of daily egg counts by quarter. It’s not scientific but it tells me which seasons hurt and helps me plan how many birds I actually need.
Top Laying Breeds That Actually Deliver {#top-breeds}
ISA Browns (and Red Sex-Links)
If you want maximum eggs with minimum hassle, ISA Browns. Period.
These are hybrid birds (Rhode Island Red x White Rock primarily, though formulations vary by hatchery). They’re not a heritage breed — they’re purpose-engineered for egg production. Under good backyard conditions, mine have averaged 5-6 eggs per week per bird in their first year. That’s roughly 280-300 eggs annually in real conditions, not marketing claims.
The tradeoffs:
- Tend to burn out faster than heritage breeds — production drops significantly after year 2-3
- Can be prone to reproductive issues (prolapse, egg binding) partly because their systems are pushed hard
- Not particularly cold-hardy compared to dedicated winter breeds
But if you want eggs now without a lot of fuss, these are the birds. Cackle Hatchery sells these; most local feed stores carry them in spring.
One underrated thing about sex-linked breeds: females and males are different colors at hatch, which means the hatchery actually knows what they’re selling you. No accidental roosters in your “pullet” purchase — and that happens more than hatcheries admit with unsexed chicks.
Leghorns (White Leghorn)
Commercial egg operations use Leghorns almost exclusively for a reason: they’re small, efficient, and lay constantly. My neighbor runs six White Leghorns and gets eggs through conditions that shut down my birds.
Leghorns are flighty and don’t appreciate handling. Not great with kids. But if production efficiency is your primary goal, they’re hard to beat — roughly 280 eggs per year from a good layer, and they eat significantly less feed than larger dual-purpose birds.
The white eggs might bother some people aesthetically. Nutritionally and functionally, identical to brown eggs — this is purely cosmetic.
Rhode Island Reds (Heritage and Production Strains)
My grandma kept Rhode Island Reds exclusively. She’d say they were stubborn, which was her way of saying they did what they wanted. But they also laid through the rough Wisconsin winters better than anything else she tried.
Two versions exist: heritage Rhode Island Reds (slower-growing, longer-lived, moderate production) and production reds (more like a hybrid, higher production). The production reds are closer to ISA Browns. Heritage reds are a more moderate, longer-term bird.
Expect 200-250 eggs per year from a heritage bird in good condition, 250-280 from production strains. Cold-tolerant. Decent temperament. Dual-purpose if you actually want to butcher the extras (heritage birds have more meat than Leghorns).
Plymouth Rocks (Barred Rock)
Barred Rocks are probably my single favorite all-around backyard hen. Calm, curious, handle cold well, lay reliably (200-280 eggs per year depending on strain), and they’re genuinely pretty birds — the black and white barring pattern is distinctive.
My oldest Barred Rock is in her fourth year and still laying a few times a week. Heritage-strain Barred Rocks tend to have better longevity than high-production hybrids. You trade peak production for a longer productive life.
Great with kids. Will follow you around the yard like a dog. Good dual-purpose bird if butchering is in the plan.
Australorps
The Australorp holds the world record for egg laying: one hen laid 364 eggs in 365 days under test conditions in the 1920s. Real backyard conditions won’t get you anywhere near that, but 250-300 eggs per year from a good Australorp hen is achievable.
They handle heat reasonably well (better than most heavy breeds) and cold well. Docile, calm temperament — one of the easiest breeds to handle. Black feathers, dark eyes, beautiful birds.
My friend runs a flock of eight Australorps in Arizona and says they’re the only breed she’s found that doesn’t collapse in summer.
Breeds for Cold Climates {#cold-hardy}
If you’re in the upper Midwest, New England, or anywhere that sees real winters, cold-hardiness matters. Birds with large single combs get frostbitten combs easily — not usually life-threatening but painful and stressful for the bird.
Buckeyes are an American breed with a rose comb — lower frostbite risk, good winter layers, calm disposition. Wyandottes have a similar comb shape, hold up well in cold, and lay around 200-240 eggs per year under real conditions. If you want something even more extreme, Chanteclers are a Canadian breed with almost no comb at all, bred specifically for northern winters. Dominiques are another heritage American bird with a rose comb and decent winter production.
For my Wisconsin winters, I add a thin layer of petroleum jelly to combs in deep cold. Takes 20 seconds per bird and prevents most frostbite. Keeps the feed going toward eggs rather than healing tissue.
What About Easter Eggers and Colored Eggs? {#colored-eggs}
Easter Eggers are mixed-breed birds that carry the blue-egg gene. They lay eggs in shades of blue, green, olive, and sometimes pink or tan. They’re not a true breed — they’re a category.
Production varies wildly because they’re not selectively bred for laying. Expect 3-4 eggs per week from a decent Easter Egger, maybe 5 from an exceptional one. Temperament is generally good.
The Ameraucana and Araucana are the true breeds behind the blue-egg gene. Ameraucanas are better-defined (tufted cheeks, beard, blue-gray slate legs) and lay consistently blue eggs. True Ameraucanas are harder to find from hatcheries — most “Ameraucanas” sold commercially are actually Easter Eggers.
My take: a few Easter Eggers in a mixed flock are fun, especially with kids who get excited about the egg colors. But don’t build your whole flock around them if production is your goal.
Breeds to Avoid If You Want Eggs {#avoid}
Silkies are beautiful, fluffy, extremely broody, and notoriously bad layers — 80-120 eggs per year from a bird that spends more time sitting on a nest than laying in one. Great pets. Terrible investment if you want eggs.
Cochins are giant, calm birds that lay about 150-180 eggs per year, which sounds okay until you account for what they eat. The math doesn’t work on a production-focused flock.
Marans lay gorgeous chocolate-brown eggs. They also produce moderately — 150-200 per year — and can be flighty and difficult. I tried a few, wanted to love them, was disappointed. Pretty eggs don’t pay the feed bill.
Old English Game birds have a fighting heritage, are extremely flighty, not suitable for family settings, and lay poorly. They keep appearing in feed stores anyway, which I genuinely don’t understand.
Mixed Flock Strategy {#mixed-flock}
Here’s what’s actually working for me after years of iteration:
About 60% of my flock is production birds — ISA Browns or Australorps, the ones that actually pay the feed cost. Another 30% or so are heritage breeds like Barred Rocks or Rhode Island Reds for longevity and hardiness. These are the birds still laying at four years old when the hybrids are spent. The last 10% is whatever I want — right now that’s a couple Easter Eggers because my boys love the blue eggs, and one Silkie because my youngest named her and she lives on the porch.
The production birds carry the weight. The heritage birds replace them as they age out. The mixed-flock approach also provides genetic diversity that makes the whole flock more resilient to disease pressure.
If you’re just starting out, start with 4-6 birds. Buying a big flock before you understand the feed cost, the management time, and whether your zoning allows roosters is how people end up rehoming chickens in Facebook groups every spring.
Buying Chicks vs. Pullets vs. Hatching Eggs {#buying-guide}
Day-old chicks are the cheapest way in per bird. The catch is you need a brooder setup for 6-8 weeks — heat lamp or plate brooder, feeders, waterers — and they won’t lay for 18-24 weeks. Most vulnerable to losses of any option.
Pullets are young hens, usually 16-20 weeks old, just starting to lay or close to it. They cost 3-5x more per bird, but you skip the brooder phase entirely and get eggs faster. Local farms, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace are where I find these. Best option for most beginners.
Hatching eggs are the cheapest per egg on paper, but you need a quality incubator, 21 days of monitoring, and you’ll hatch roughly 50% roosters that you’ll need to deal with somehow. Not where I’d start.
For most people starting a backyard flock: buy pullets from a local farm or reputable hatchery, choose a cold-hardy dual-purpose breed for your climate, and start with 4-6 birds before scaling up. The backyard chickens guide covers coop setup and management in detail.
What I’d Actually Buy Today {#what-id-buy}
The lineup I’m running now in my Wisconsin yard — 4 Australorps, 4 Barred Rocks, 2 Wyandottes, and 2 Easter Eggers. The Australorps carry the production load through winter. The Barred Rocks are still going strong at 3-4 years old when the hybrids are done. Wyandottes are my cold-insurance because they lay through the hard Wisconsin stretches. And the Easter Eggers are for the kids — simple as that.
A few mistakes I see people make constantly, because I made them too: buying based on looks first (my first flock was partly a feather-color decision), starting with too many birds before you understand the feed cost, ignoring your climate entirely (a Leghorn through a real Minnesota winter is a miserable bird), and buying straight-run chicks when you have no plan for roosters. If a hatchery sells “straight-run,” that means half roosters. Buy sexed pullets unless you want a problem. And budget the feed before you buy anything — a laying hen eats roughly a quarter pound per day, which adds up faster than it sounds.
My grandma would have had opinions about all of this. She kept chickens the way she kept everything — practically, without sentiment (except for a rooster named Duke who lived to 9 years because she said he was “too mean to eat”). She picked breeds that worked, fed them well, and didn’t overmanage them.
That’s still the right approach. Pick birds that fit your climate and your goals. Give them decent housing and feed. And resist the urge to name them all.
I’ve named every single one of ours. It doesn’t help the egg count but it does make mornings better.